b 6 Marks

Differentiate between LNG and CNG.

Answer: Difference Between LNG and CNG

1. Basic Definitions

CNG (Compressed Natural Gas): Natural gas (primarily methane) stored at high pressure (200-250 bar / 2900-3600 psi) in gaseous state at ambient temperature.

LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas): Natural gas cooled to extremely low temperature (-162°C / -260°F) converting it to liquid form, reducing volume by approximately 600 times.

2. Detailed Comparison Table

Parameter CNG (Compressed Natural Gas) LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas)
Physical State Gas (compressed) Liquid (cryogenic)
Storage Condition High pressure: 200-250 bar at ambient temperature Low temperature: -162°C at atmospheric pressure
Volume Reduction ~1/200 of natural gas volume ~1/600 of natural gas volume
Energy Density Lower (~9 MJ/liter) Higher (~22 MJ/liter)
Storage Tanks Heavy, thick-walled steel/composite cylinders Double-walled insulated cryogenic tanks
Production Process Compression using compressors Liquefaction requiring cooling plants
Infrastructure Cost Lower (compression stations) Higher (liquefaction, regasification terminals)
Transportation Pipelines, cascades for short distances Ships, tankers for long distances; trucks for distribution
Primary Applications Light vehicles (cars, buses, auto-rickshaws) Heavy vehicles (trucks), ships, industrial use, long-distance trade
Vehicle Range Limited (150-300 km) due to lower energy density Longer (500-1000 km) due to higher energy density
Refueling Time Fast (3-5 minutes) Slower (10-15 minutes for trucks)
Safety Concerns High pressure risk; lighter than air (disperses quickly) Cryogenic burns; boil-off gas management
India Infrastructure 3500+ CNG stations; expanding CGD network 6 LNG import terminals; limited LNG dispensing stations

3. Advantages and Disadvantages

CNG - Advantages:

CNG - Disadvantages:

LNG - Advantages:

LNG - Disadvantages:

4. Applications Comparison

Application CNG LNG
Cars & Light Vehicles ✓ Preferred ✗ Not practical
City Buses ✓ Widely used ○ Emerging
Auto-rickshaws ✓ Preferred ✗ Not used
Long-haul Trucks ✗ Limited range ✓ Preferred
Ships/Marine ✗ Not practical ✓ Growing rapidly
Industrial Use ○ Limited ✓ Power, heating
International Trade ✗ Not feasible ✓ Primary method

5. India Context

CNG in India: 35+ lakh CNG vehicles; 3,500+ stations; Major cities - Delhi NCR, Mumbai, Gujarat, Pune

LNG in India: 6 import terminals (42.5 MMTPA capacity); Growing LNG trucking pilots; GAIL's LNG distribution network

6. Environmental Comparison

Conclusion

CNG and LNG are both forms of natural gas but differ fundamentally in their physical state, storage method, and applications. CNG (compressed gas at high pressure) is ideal for light vehicles and urban transport where refueling infrastructure exists. LNG (liquefied at cryogenic temperatures) offers higher energy density, making it suitable for heavy-duty, long-distance transport and international trade. In India's transition to cleaner fuels, CNG dominates urban transport while LNG is emerging for long-haul trucking and as an import fuel to meet growing gas demand. Both play important roles in reducing transport emissions compared to traditional petroleum fuels.

Sources: Module 2 Notes | PPAC India | GAIL | Cummins Natural Gas | US DOE AFDC